It was a brutal, painful and disgraceful loss to Trinidad and Tobago. I didn’t want to write and I didn’t want to believe what I had just watched. Days before the blowout win against Panama I had told a good friend I was more nervous about Trinidad and Tobago. I predicted a 3-0 win over Panama and that we we would dominate likely with a first five minute goal. I couldn’t make a prediction for T&T, but even that sick feeling I had didn’t do anything to prepare me for the game. After a lengthy time to process and reflect as a huge fan of USMNT, I have sough out understanding and hope. I will try to share some of the both here.
The trouble began long ago, we started out of the 2014 cycle with several loses and very little to be excited about. Bobby Wood became a spark of hope in friendly wins against Netherlands and Germany, but there was little else to be excited about for our first year post an incredibly exciting World Cup group stage and near win against Belgium. Word that Tim Howard wanted to take a year off of US soccer in 2015 started us down a rough course.
Bobby Wood’s game winning goal against Holland:
The continued use of older players like Nick Rimando, Kyle Beckerman, Chris Wondolowski and slew of MLS players began to create doubt in Coach Jurgen Klinsmann’s plan of transforming our style of play into the attacking soccer we were promised. Brad Guzan seemed to be our only option in goal which was for many a huge disappointment along with the continued poor use and play of Michael Bradley. Many were calling for Fabian Johnson to get a shot in the midfield and moments of excitement in seeing Sebastian Klijstan playing well were cause for confusion when he was benched for no reason again. The fourth place finish in the 2015 Gold Cup was a real low point for a disappointing year and pressure began to mount for Jurgen Klinsmann.
The 2016 Copa America semi-final was another exciting run of soccer and while few new faces emerged, there was a nice run of play. Geoff Cameron and John Brooks were developing a nice pairing and Brooks was getting great attention abroad. DeAndre Yedlin had broken into Europe and was playing well in a US jersey. Christian Pulisic was starting to get international recognition and critical minutes for Dortmund and Bobby Wood was turning into a legitimately dangerous striker in Germany. The blowout to Argentina stunted that momentum though – a starting lineup that included those same poor player pool of including Guzan who’s indecisive weaknesses shone, Beckerman, Graham Zusi, Gyasi Zardes were not nearly fast enough or dangerous enough to even put together a single shot in the game. While getting far in the tournament was exciting, it never really felt like we were turning a corner as a team or that we could threaten to develop into a formidable team. Pulisic entered the game late and gave an immediate spark, but he was far too along against a powerhouse to be dangerous. This gap between his ability and the rest of the team was a constant for the next three years.
The year ended with a crushing loss to Mexico and a blowout defeat in Costa Rica putting an end to Jurgen Klinsmann’s era, a decision I agreed with at the time and stand by. Klinsmann didn’t have the answers. The Bruce Arena era started well as it brought belief again with winning and undefeated ways. It looked like he was going to put reasonable lineups and actually play players in their correct positions. Michael Bradley looked transformed back in time to his early post-Europe days where he looked confident and like a general on the field. As the crucial qualifying year churned on though, the lineups began to show cracks. Graham Zusi and DaMarcus Beasley kept showing up on defense – one player out of position and the other had already retired years before. The midfield couldn’t quite get right and players like Zardes coming off of a broken leg, Wondolowski and Rimando kept showing up. Arena went so far as to say he had no interest in planning for the future only to survive and make it to World Cup 2018. He then hitched his wagon to MLS almost removing European based players from the lineups outside of Pulisic and Wood and the cycle ended in a devastating, embarrassing loss to Trinidad and Tobago.
It took me a long time to emotionally be ready to write after that brutal loss. As I watch the landscape and reflect on the last four years I really only see Christian Pulisic as the lone legitimate bright spot out of the cycle. Wood and Yedlin emergence in Europe could be foundational players moving forward if they continue to develop for the next cycle and should be two of only a small handful of players that should be retained on the next roster. I think Paul Arriola and Kellyn Acosta are two others who should be considered and very little else from Bruce’s final lineup.
We don’t yet know the damage left in the wake of the loss for our youth movement’s future, but under Arena it’s unlikely many that deserve it would have been called up anyway. The popularity of the game likely takes a big hit as does the pursuit of the advertising opportunities and funding around the sport. Perhaps though, in the long run the loss will be the shake up we need from top to bottom.
The animosity and anger that exploded through the ranks of fans and pundits alike could transform the very nature of the approach to the game. We are seeing a lot of interest from Europe in the coaching job and hopefully that competition and drive brings out the best replacement coach that we can find. Almost every big name in US soccer has stepped forward and is considering a run at President for a role that has for cycles gone unchallenged. Super fans of the USMNT can only hope that starting with the election in 2018 for USSF President down to our next coach and even in the ranks of youth development we might get the real transformation that our little victories have falsely led us to believe were there. Our U17 team and U20 team’s successes as their prospective World Cups should also be recognized and hopefully many of these players get more international attention thanks to Pulisic, Wood and Yedlin’s effort through the last cycle. Bill Hamid has just announced his plan to move to Europe to try to take over as the future keeper for USMNT. In England Yedlin’s success is helping a movement and eyes are still on Lynden Gooch (Sunderland) and Matthew Olosunde (Manchester) among others trying to break into the Premier League. There are several young centrebacks including Matt Miagza (Chelsea), Erik Palmer-Brown (Manchester City) and Cameron Carter-Vickers (Tottenham) that have real potential. We have midfielders and forward scattered across the Bundasliga including Weston McKinnie who has cracked the starting lineup at Schalke, Haji Wright and Josh Sargant was just signed by Werder Bremen. If our U17 team makes a deep run in the current World Cup there’s a good chance that players like Timothy Weah (PSG), Andrew Carleton (Atlanta United), Ayo Akinola (Toronto FC), and Chris Durkin (DC United) get a deeper look. Weah scored a hat trick last week and if PSG isn’t using him, there may be other clubs who take an interest in the young forward.
Timothy Weah’s impressive hat trick at the 2018 U17 World Cup:
There are 11 players and even 25 players that can proudly wear a US jersey and challenge top teams in the world. It’ll take a joint effort from youth development, to MLS and the academies, to youth team success for European club signings, relationships with Europe to get our players plugged in and used to a coach who calls in the right players and builds a system for them to succeed. They’re out there and we are a country that can develop and put those pieces together.
I’m a Red Sox fan who never though 2004 was going to happen, maybe that’s led me to be too optimistic, but as for me … I BELIEVE THAT WE CAN WIN!
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
I said after Mauricio Pochettino’s extension that I didn’t expect him to make it through the 2030 cycle as #USMNT manager, whether due to results or another club offering him a deal he couldn’t refuse. However, I never expected things to reach this point so close to the start of the cycle.
In some ways, the timing might not be the worst, provided US Soccer can quickly interview and hire a replacement well before the March FIFA window. That said, I was really starting to buy into Pochettino’s vision and his commitment to building the #USMNT around youth.
Hopefully, US Soccer recognizes the value of having a high-profile manager and pursues another big name like Pep Guardiola, Didier Deschamps or Julian Nagelsmann. My gut, however, tells me they’ll pivot back toward an American coach or an experienced MLS manager like Wilfried Nancy.
Another intriguing option is Marko Mitrović, former U19, U20 and U23 USMNT manager and current New England Revolution coach. He already has experience working with many of the young players in the current player pool.
Here’s a look at some of the most likely American candidates to become the next USMNT manager.
Michael Bradley (39)
I truly believe Michael Bradley will someday manage the USMNT. His soccer intelligence, leadership qualities, and playing experience across Europe and MLS give him both an international perspective and a deep understanding of American soccer culture. However, Bradley likely projects more as a candidate for the 2034 cycle at the earliest and he still needs time to develop at the club level.
B. J. Callaghan (45)
It would be difficult not to include B.J. Callaghan after the positive impression he made as interim USMNT manager. Coming off an MLS-best record and Supporters’ Shield title, Callaghan continues to demonstrate his ability to prepare and get the most out of his teams despite a relatively limited managerial résumé. He earned the trust of the players and fans by delivered strong performances during his time with the national team. If the position opens again, U.S. Soccer would almost certainly explore his interest.
Steve Cherundolo (47)
Steve Cherundolo may be one cycle away from becoming a serious candidate, especially after recently leaving MLS to return to Germany. Still, his experience as both a player and manager at high levels of the game makes him someone U.S. Soccer should strongly consider.
Jim Curtin (47)
If Pochettino can be convinced to leave the #USMNT, perhaps newly appointed Austin FC manager Jim Curtin could also be persuaded to make the move if U.S. Soccer views him as the right fit. His success with the Philadelphia Union, highlighted by winning the 2020 Supporters’ Shield, showcased his ability to build a strong team culture and maximize the talent at his disposal.
Pellegrino Matarazzo (48)
I’m not convinced U.S. Soccer would seriously pursue Pellegrino Matarazzo, but hopefully I’m wrong. His success coaching in Europe has made him one of the most respected American-born managers in the game and a popular choice among many fans for the future of the USMNT.
Brian Schmetzer (63)
With eight trophies to his name, Brian Schmetzer may be one of the strongest and most accomplished domestic candidates available. His biggest achievement came when he led Seattle Sounders FC to the 2022 CONCACAF Champions League title, becoming the first MLS club to win the tournament under its modern format.
Peter Vermes (59)
Former USMNT striker Peter Vermes deserves consideration given his success at Sporting KC, where he won four trophies as a manager. Vermes previously turned down interest from U.S. Soccer, but with him no longer actively coaching at club level, the timing could finally align for a move into the international game.
The Importance of Having a Succession Plan
The next USMNT manager could inherit a player pool filled with established veterans and exciting young talent, but U.S. Soccer’s vision and priorities have shifted frequently between cycles. If Pochettino is indeed leaving, that could send the federation in a different direction with its next hire.
My hope is that the long-term vision remains consistent with the approach heading into the 2022 World Cup. Given that Pochettino’s contract reportedly included a $10 million buyout clause, you would hope U.S. Soccer had contingency plans and potential replacements in mind. In recent cycles, the federation has appeared less prepared with backup options than it was in the past. How quickly U.S. Soccer moves will be important, but the search cannot drag on indefinitely. A process lasting a few months is reasonable, provided the federation identifies the right candidate well ahead of the next major FIFA window.
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
With the next wave of highly rated teenagers likely to be brought into the #USMNT during the 2030 World Cup cycle, I decided to look back at some of the young players who were once hyped as the next stars of the U.S. Men’s National Team but never established themselves as regular internationals.
Freddy Adu would seem to be at the top of this list. While he never became a regular for the #USMNT or the world-class face of U.S. Soccer many expected, he still earned 17 caps, scoring 2 goals and adding 3 assists. In many ways, he accomplished more at the international level than most of the players who are listed below combined.
Which former USMNT prospects did I miss, players who are no longer playing or are past their prime, who deserve to be on this list?
Cody Cropper – GK – 0 caps
U.S. youth international and longtime goalkeeper prospect who reached the Southampton and MLS systems but never earned a senior cap.
Junior Flores – AM – 0 caps
Creative midfielder who joined Borussia Dortmund’s system as a teenager and was viewed as a major U.S. prospect, but never reached the senior USMNT.
Eddie Gaven – MF/W – 8 caps
Teenage MLS phenom who became a league standout, but despite eight USMNT appearances, his international career never developed further.
Luis Gil – AM – 2 caps
One of the most hyped American midfield prospects of his generation; debuted for RSL at 16 but never translated that promise into a sustained USMNT career.
Emerson Hyndman – MF – 2 caps
Highly rated central midfielder who broke through at Fulham and earned two USMNT appearances, but never established himself internationally.
Perry Kitchen – DM/CB – 5 caps
U.S. youth captain and defensive midfielder who became a regular MLS starter, but his senior international career stalled after five caps.
Will Packwood – CB/DM – 0 caps
Birmingham City prospect who became the youngest American to play in the English Championship, but injuries severely disrupted his development.
Marc Pelosi – LB/CB – 0 caps
Highly regarded defender who moved to Liverpool as a teenager, but injuries and limited senior opportunities derailed his path to the USMNT.
Gedion Zelalem – MF – 0 caps
Arsenal wonderkid and one of the most highly regarded U.S. prospects of his generation. Injuries and inconsistent senior opportunities slowed his development, and he never made a senior USMNT appearance.
The number of young USMNT players in this September/October window is something we haven’t seen in quite some time. Some will catch the eye of newly extended USMNT manager Mauricio Pochettino, while others may not, but all of them have an opportunity during this cycle to make their case for World Cup qualifying and, ultimately, a spot on the 2026 World Cup roster.
It all starts now, and it should be fun to follow their development over the next four years.
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
Header_NextGen
With the USMNT manager in place and the new cycle underway it’s time for recently extended Mauricio Pochettino to get some new young players on his radar and what better time to do this than the September/October double FIFA window.
There are several U-23 players like Josh Wynder, Jalen Neal, Rokas Pukstas, Diego Kochen, Jonathan Gomez, Caleb Wiley, Cole Campbell, Chris Brady, Gaga, Slonina, Niko Tsakiris, Damion Downs, and Benjamin Cremaschi who have no caps order less than a handful with the USMNT.
Will USMNT snubs or overlooked players opportunities be during the 2030 cycle look like? Players like Diego Luna, Tanner Tessmann, Aidan Morris and Camron Carter-Vickers to name a few, we have to wonder how or if they will be part of this cycle of players. I would suggest some will likely get the opportunity in the early part of the cycle but will need to be performing n with their club to remain getting called back into camps.
Integrating a few of these youth USMNT players during each window for the first half of the cycle will allow Pochettino to evaluate them up close and see if there might be a role for them during this next cycle.
It’s extremely important that the USMNT have a few on their current U-20 teenagers’ breakthrough and become a reliable part of the USMNT in the second half of the cycle.
The below players will have an opportunity to play in next years U-20 World Cup being hosted by Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan as well as hopefully if their clubs release them being part of the 2028 Olympics USA Football squad to hopefully medal for the first time since 1904 when the US had two teams win Silver and Bronze. I think it’s also important to look at these players alongside some of the core USMNT in the upcoming window to see how they can integrate with one another.
Mathis Albert-17-Winger
Noahkai Banks-19-Centerback
Cole Campbell-20-Midfielder/Winger
Zavier Gozo-19-Winger
Julian Hall-18-Winger
Malik Jakupovic-17-Striker
Adri Mehmeti-17-Central Midfielder
Peyton Miller-18-Left Midfielder/Winger
Neil Pierre-18-Centerback
Cavan Sullivan-16-Attacking Midfielder
Whether we see all of these players, or just a handful, through the first half of the cycle, hopefully leading into another Copa América appearance, it’s clear that the time has come for Pochettino to begin integrating the next generation of USMNT players into the senior pool. How quickly that transition happens will be one of the most interesting storylines to follow.