Major League Soccer is looking to once again change their MLS Cup Playoff format which I have to assume is finically motivated headed into the 2026 cycle with the USA along with Canada and Mexico will be hosting the World Cup.
Here’s a look back at the changes and or expanded its playoffs many times over its existence and here’s how it’s changed over the last 26 years.
1996-1999 (8 Teams with a minimum of 13 Matches to a maximum of 19 matches)
In the first four seasons of the MLS, the playoffs included eight teams, which would play a best-of-three series to advance to the Conference Semifinals and Conference Finals. No ties were allowed and teams would go to penalty kicks to determine the winner of the match. The MLS Cup Final would be a one-match fixture.
2000-2002 (8 Teams with a minimum of 13 Matches to a maximum of 19 matches, The Best of Three series still remained, but with an added Point System)
In 2000 Major League Soccer made a slight change to the playoff format by adding a points system, which gave a team 3 points for a win, 1 point for a draw & zero points for a loss, with a team needing 5 points to advance to the next round, with the best of three series still being used. As needed, the Added Sudden Death Extra Time (ASDET) and Sudden Death Extra Time (SDET) were included during the playoffs. The MLS Cup Final remained a one match fixture.
2003-2010 (8 Teams and 11 Matches Played)
In 2003 the MLS once again changed their playoff format and instead of the best-of-three series so that the Conference Semifinal would be a two-legged home and away aggregate series. The team who had the higher seed would play their home game in the second leg of the series. The Conference Finals would become a one match fixture with the MLS Cup Final continuing to be a single match.
2011 (10 Teams and 13 Matches Played)
2011 was the first playoff series to include ten MLS teams with the playoffs containing four teams (seventh, eighth, ninth & tenth seeds) participating in a Play-In round match, which happened to include a crossover series with the Columbus Crew (Eastern Table) playing Colorado Rapids (Western Table) and the New York Red Bulls (Eastern Table) playing FC Dallas (Western Table) The Conference Semifinals, Finals, and MLS Cup format would remain the same as previously played.
2012-2014 (10 Teams and 15 Matches Played)
In 2012 the Play-In (Wildcard) removed the crossover series seen only in 2011. The first round would only be a one-off match between the fourth and fifth-place teams from each Conference. Conference Semifinals and Conference Championship series were conducted in a home-and-away aggregate-goal format. The lower-seeded team in the Conference Semifinal hosts the first game, and the higher-seed hosts the second. The MLS Cup Final would remain a one-match fixture.
2015-2018 (12 Teams and 17 Matches Played)
Two-legged home-and-away series for with 1 match Knockout Round (3rd, 4th, 5th & 6th Seeds in each Conference)
In 2015 the MLS would once again increase the number of teams who made the playoff from 10 teams to 12 teams. The first round would only be a one-off matches between the third, fourth fifth, and sixth-place teams from each Conference. The Semifinals, Finals, and MLS playoff format would remain the same as previously played.
2019, 2021-Current (14 Teams and 13 Matches Played)
In 2019 the top seven teams in each conference advanced to a single elimination bracket, with the top team in each conference earning a first-round bye.
2020 (18 Teams and 17 Matches Played)
Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the MLS announced that the final regular season standings and playoff qualification would be determined by points per game rather than by overall points since not all teams were able to play the 23 regular season games.
The would also be a play-in round where the seventh-place Nashville SC played and beat the tenth-placed Inter Miami CF while the eighth-place team, the New England Revolution, beat the ninth-placed team, the Montreal Impact.
The higher seed team hosted matches for the first three rounds with the regular season team with the best record to host the MLS Cup Final.
In 2021 we would see the MLS return to the newest playoff format they used during the 2019 season, which fans seemed to embrace for its expedited format and with the overall attendance at the MLS Cup Playoff matches has been good but I have to wonder what expanding the playoff matches by nearly double does for soccer in the USA during an already busy fall sports season, but it seems like we will find out very soon.
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
I said after Mauricio Pochettino’s extension that I didn’t expect him to make it through the 2030 cycle as #USMNT manager, whether due to results or another club offering him a deal he couldn’t refuse. However, I never expected things to reach this point so close to the start of the cycle.
In some ways, the timing might not be the worst, provided US Soccer can quickly interview and hire a replacement well before the March FIFA window. That said, I was really starting to buy into Pochettino’s vision and his commitment to building the #USMNT around youth.
Hopefully, US Soccer recognizes the value of having a high-profile manager and pursues another big name like Pep Guardiola, Didier Deschamps or Julian Nagelsmann. My gut, however, tells me they’ll pivot back toward an American coach or an experienced MLS manager like Wilfried Nancy.
Another intriguing option is Marko Mitrović, former U19, U20 and U23 USMNT manager and current New England Revolution coach. He already has experience working with many of the young players in the current player pool.
Here’s a look at some of the most likely American candidates to become the next USMNT manager.
Michael Bradley (39)
I truly believe Michael Bradley will someday manage the USMNT. His soccer intelligence, leadership qualities, and playing experience across Europe and MLS give him both an international perspective and a deep understanding of American soccer culture. However, Bradley likely projects more as a candidate for the 2034 cycle at the earliest and he still needs time to develop at the club level.
B. J. Callaghan (45)
It would be difficult not to include B.J. Callaghan after the positive impression he made as interim USMNT manager. Coming off an MLS-best record and Supporters’ Shield title, Callaghan continues to demonstrate his ability to prepare and get the most out of his teams despite a relatively limited managerial résumé. He earned the trust of the players and fans by delivered strong performances during his time with the national team. If the position opens again, U.S. Soccer would almost certainly explore his interest.
Steve Cherundolo (47)
Steve Cherundolo may be one cycle away from becoming a serious candidate, especially after recently leaving MLS to return to Germany. Still, his experience as both a player and manager at high levels of the game makes him someone U.S. Soccer should strongly consider.
Jim Curtin (47)
If Pochettino can be convinced to leave the #USMNT, perhaps newly appointed Austin FC manager Jim Curtin could also be persuaded to make the move if U.S. Soccer views him as the right fit. His success with the Philadelphia Union, highlighted by winning the 2020 Supporters’ Shield, showcased his ability to build a strong team culture and maximize the talent at his disposal.
Pellegrino Matarazzo (48)
I’m not convinced U.S. Soccer would seriously pursue Pellegrino Matarazzo, but hopefully I’m wrong. His success coaching in Europe has made him one of the most respected American-born managers in the game and a popular choice among many fans for the future of the USMNT.
Brian Schmetzer (63)
With eight trophies to his name, Brian Schmetzer may be one of the strongest and most accomplished domestic candidates available. His biggest achievement came when he led Seattle Sounders FC to the 2022 CONCACAF Champions League title, becoming the first MLS club to win the tournament under its modern format.
Peter Vermes (59)
Former USMNT striker Peter Vermes deserves consideration given his success at Sporting KC, where he won four trophies as a manager. Vermes previously turned down interest from U.S. Soccer, but with him no longer actively coaching at club level, the timing could finally align for a move into the international game.
The Importance of Having a Succession Plan
The next USMNT manager could inherit a player pool filled with established veterans and exciting young talent, but U.S. Soccer’s vision and priorities have shifted frequently between cycles. If Pochettino is indeed leaving, that could send the federation in a different direction with its next hire.
My hope is that the long-term vision remains consistent with the approach heading into the 2022 World Cup. Given that Pochettino’s contract reportedly included a $10 million buyout clause, you would hope U.S. Soccer had contingency plans and potential replacements in mind. In recent cycles, the federation has appeared less prepared with backup options than it was in the past. How quickly U.S. Soccer moves will be important, but the search cannot drag on indefinitely. A process lasting a few months is reasonable, provided the federation identifies the right candidate well ahead of the next major FIFA window.
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
With the next wave of highly rated teenagers likely to be brought into the #USMNT during the 2030 World Cup cycle, I decided to look back at some of the young players who were once hyped as the next stars of the U.S. Men’s National Team but never established themselves as regular internationals.
Freddy Adu would seem to be at the top of this list. While he never became a regular for the #USMNT or the world-class face of U.S. Soccer many expected, he still earned 17 caps, scoring 2 goals and adding 3 assists. In many ways, he accomplished more at the international level than most of the players who are listed below combined.
Which former USMNT prospects did I miss, players who are no longer playing or are past their prime, who deserve to be on this list?
Cody Cropper – GK – 0 caps
U.S. youth international and longtime goalkeeper prospect who reached the Southampton and MLS systems but never earned a senior cap.
Junior Flores – AM – 0 caps
Creative midfielder who joined Borussia Dortmund’s system as a teenager and was viewed as a major U.S. prospect, but never reached the senior USMNT.
Eddie Gaven – MF/W – 8 caps
Teenage MLS phenom who became a league standout, but despite eight USMNT appearances, his international career never developed further.
Luis Gil – AM – 2 caps
One of the most hyped American midfield prospects of his generation; debuted for RSL at 16 but never translated that promise into a sustained USMNT career.
Emerson Hyndman – MF – 2 caps
Highly rated central midfielder who broke through at Fulham and earned two USMNT appearances, but never established himself internationally.
Perry Kitchen – DM/CB – 5 caps
U.S. youth captain and defensive midfielder who became a regular MLS starter, but his senior international career stalled after five caps.
Will Packwood – CB/DM – 0 caps
Birmingham City prospect who became the youngest American to play in the English Championship, but injuries severely disrupted his development.
Marc Pelosi – LB/CB – 0 caps
Highly regarded defender who moved to Liverpool as a teenager, but injuries and limited senior opportunities derailed his path to the USMNT.
Gedion Zelalem – MF – 0 caps
Arsenal wonderkid and one of the most highly regarded U.S. prospects of his generation. Injuries and inconsistent senior opportunities slowed his development, and he never made a senior USMNT appearance.
The number of young USMNT players in this September/October window is something we haven’t seen in quite some time. Some will catch the eye of newly extended USMNT manager Mauricio Pochettino, while others may not, but all of them have an opportunity during this cycle to make their case for World Cup qualifying and, ultimately, a spot on the 2026 World Cup roster.
It all starts now, and it should be fun to follow their development over the next four years.
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
Header_NextGen
With the USMNT manager in place and the new cycle underway it’s time for recently extended Mauricio Pochettino to get some new young players on his radar and what better time to do this than the September/October double FIFA window.
There are several U-23 players like Josh Wynder, Jalen Neal, Rokas Pukstas, Diego Kochen, Jonathan Gomez, Caleb Wiley, Cole Campbell, Chris Brady, Gaga, Slonina, Niko Tsakiris, Damion Downs, and Benjamin Cremaschi who have no caps order less than a handful with the USMNT.
Will USMNT snubs or overlooked players opportunities be during the 2030 cycle look like? Players like Diego Luna, Tanner Tessmann, Aidan Morris and Camron Carter-Vickers to name a few, we have to wonder how or if they will be part of this cycle of players. I would suggest some will likely get the opportunity in the early part of the cycle but will need to be performing n with their club to remain getting called back into camps.
Integrating a few of these youth USMNT players during each window for the first half of the cycle will allow Pochettino to evaluate them up close and see if there might be a role for them during this next cycle.
It’s extremely important that the USMNT have a few on their current U-20 teenagers’ breakthrough and become a reliable part of the USMNT in the second half of the cycle.
The below players will have an opportunity to play in next years U-20 World Cup being hosted by Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan as well as hopefully if their clubs release them being part of the 2028 Olympics USA Football squad to hopefully medal for the first time since 1904 when the US had two teams win Silver and Bronze. I think it’s also important to look at these players alongside some of the core USMNT in the upcoming window to see how they can integrate with one another.
Mathis Albert-17-Winger
Noahkai Banks-19-Centerback
Cole Campbell-20-Midfielder/Winger
Zavier Gozo-19-Winger
Julian Hall-18-Winger
Malik Jakupovic-17-Striker
Adri Mehmeti-17-Central Midfielder
Peyton Miller-18-Left Midfielder/Winger
Neil Pierre-18-Centerback
Cavan Sullivan-16-Attacking Midfielder
Whether we see all of these players, or just a handful, through the first half of the cycle, hopefully leading into another Copa América appearance, it’s clear that the time has come for Pochettino to begin integrating the next generation of USMNT players into the senior pool. How quickly that transition happens will be one of the most interesting storylines to follow.