World Cup Qualifying is hard everywhere. World Cup Qualifying in Concacaf is a nightmare. A young and inexperienced USMNT is baptized by fire for two weeks, setting out to right the wrongs of the 2018 cycle.
River To Russia Qatar
Nashville, United States of America
US Soccer chooses Nashville to host the first home match. As such, the team meet and train in the city before traveling to El Salvador for the first qualifier. In a bizarre twist of fate, the remnants of Hurricane Ida move right over the city, bringing large amounts of rain and painful memories.
Couva, Trinidad and Tobago
10th of October, 2017
The World Cup is on the line. One point, only one point. Just do not lose and the US is going to Russia.
Heavy rain, high humidity, flooded pitch. “River to Russia.” Just a draw, that is all. Just draw. Only 1,500 fans. They only have three points. Just draw.
Kickoff. 17th minute an embarrassing own goal. One goal down. There is plenty of time. Just one goal. Just one.
37th minute a chip from midfield. Two goals down. This can not be happening. Tired legs. Poor play. No energy. Halftime.
Dempsey on to start the second half. Christian Pulisic, the US Wunderkind, 47th minute puts it away. There is hope. Just one more.
77th minute, Dempsey off the post. So close, yet so far.
Elsewhere, Panama scores a ghost goal. The only way is to win. Just one more.
One more would not come.
Full time. A loss. Heartbreak. Tears. Unimaginable pain. The United States has failed to qualify for the 2018 World Cup.
The River to Russia claims its victim.
Rain, flooding, humidity and memories hang over Nashville at the start of qualifying. As the rain comes down, the images mirror those of Couva. A new cycle and a new squad, but the same ever-present fear. The River to Russia is now the River to Qatar.
While fans have one eye on the past and one on the future, a young team with very little experience sets out to change hearts and minds. A grueling journey that tests the limits of even the most veteran of squads. With the pain of Couva and weight of expectations on their shoulders, the squad boards a plane to El Salvador.
1,423 Days
San Salvador, El Salvador
2nd of September, 2021
Concacaf World Cup Qualifying is back. The USMNT takes the pitch for the first time in Qualifiers since Couva. A total of 1,423 days. Very few players remain from that night. The current USMNT is filled with young players from the best leagues. A squad bursting with talent, but lacking in experience.
No amount of talk can prepare for Concacaf away. Poor pitch conditions, projectiles, riot police, humidity and an extremely hostile crowd can not be prepared for. It is something this group learns walking out alongside the riot police. Gio Reyna jumps during the national anthem as a firework is set off. An action that reminds everyone how inexperienced this squad really is.
Without captains Christian Pulisic (COVID recovery) and Zack Steffen (back spasms), the USMNT kicks off World Cup Qualifying. Defender Miles Robinson has a chance early, but misplaces his header. Later, midfielder Weston McKennie does the same. The nerves are obvious in the poor touches, misplaced passes and poor shots. Defensively, it is nervous but solid. El Salvador never gets a clear chance.
In true Concacaf away fashion, Gio Reyna is protected by Riot Police as projectiles are thrown at him from the stands
It ends 0-0. A point on the road is usually an acceptable result. It is not this time. The chances to win are there, but they are not taken. Chances must be taken. Two points are dropped even though they should not have been. At the end of the day, every point matters. Letting two points slip away is not good enough.
Despite the chances to win and El Salvador’s lack of true goal-scoring chances, the performance is bad. The team is disjointed and overwhelmed. Fans, media and former players all criticize Gregg Berhalter.
However, there is not time to dwell on the result. With three matches in six days, focus quickly shifts to Canada in Nashville.
Concacaf Qualifying 101: Win At Home
Nashville, United States of America
5th of September, 2021
The first rule of Concacaf World Cup Qualifying: Win at Home. Winning every home match will almost guarantee World Cup qualification.
USMNT fans pack into Nissan Stadium. The American Outlaws have three sections reserved behind the goal. They are ready to go with their drums, banners, voices and tifos. 43,028 fans fill Nissan Stadium, most expecting a win and all three points.
The American Outlaw drummers get chants started during player warmups
The first half is end-to-end. Canada have chances and so do the USMNT. Pulisic, back from Covid recovery, hits the post. The USMNT struggles in transition, containing Alphonso Davies and in possession. As the half comes to an end, US right-back Sergiño Dest goes down with an ankle injury. His injury forces Berhalter to make a first half change.
Brenden Aaronson scores for the US in the second half. The fans in the stadium are jumping. Not even 10 minutes later, Canada equalizes. The energy in the stadium shifts and the fan energy dies.
Clinging to a draw, USMNT substitutes are finally introduced in the 83rd minute. They are too little too late. The match ends 1-1. A lucky result for the USMNT. The players solute The American Outlaws to boos and half-hearted sarcastic applause.
There is no way around it, a draw at home is not good enough. It is unacceptable.
Gregg Berhalter is the target of fan anger. Calls for his removal re-start. For the fans, the only acceptable result is an away win at Honduras. A seemingly impossible task.
Poor Choices
Nashville, United States of America
Controversy and drama are stables of Concacaf World Cup Qualifying. Every team will have something happen. That is how it is in Concacaf.
For the USMNT, drama hits in the form of a team captain, Weston McKennie, violating team and Covid policy. As a result, McKennie is suspended for the Canada and Honduras matches.
Weston McKennie apologizes shortly before kickoff of USA vs CAN
The aftermath of the Canada draw, pulls attention to McKennie’s suspension. Details are hard to come by. Sources give out information skeptically. US Soccer and Gregg Berhalter refuse to release the details of the violation.
USMNT journalists eventually confirm McKennie brought an unauthorized individual into the team hotel and left the team bubble.
A Tale of Two Halves
San Pedro Sula, Honduras
8th of September, 2021
Forcing the drama of the past few days out of minds, the USMNT walks onto the pitch for the third time in six days knowing only a win will suffice.
The first few minutes are end-to-end. Then Honduras scores. It triggers a USMNT collapse. The rest of the first half is almost unbearable. The USMNT struggle to complete anything. Attack, defense and transition is a mess. By sheer luck the US is only 1-0 down at halftime.
The first half is one of the worst USMNT performances in years. Changes are needed. In the broadcast studio, USMNT legend Clint Dempsey says he can go 15-20 minutes. On Twitter, fans call for him to get on the next flight.
Tactical and personnel changes are made to start the second half, both for Honduras and the USMNT. The changes work in the USMNT’s favor. Within minutes the US equalizes. The battle resumes with end-to-end play once again.
The flood gates open with 15 minutes to go. The US pulls ahead. Then scores another. Then adds a fourth in stoppage time. Each goal moves the USMNT further up the table and stitches the wounds of the first five halves of World Cup Qualifying. Each of the four goals helps make things right.
Ricardo Pepi celebrates his first USMNT goal, the winning goal
A comeback story for the ages is written. In the process the USMNT finds their fight. The fight that brought home two trophies in one summer. The fight that will carry the team to Qatar, the fight that was absent that night in Couva.
The first qualifying window is complete. Three matches and nine points are off the calendar. Despite nervous and downright bad performances, five out of nine available points are collected. The USMNT is on track to Qatar 2022.
In 4 weeks, it happens all over again. There will be a different set of players and three new matches. They will have nine more points available for the taking.
Over the decades, the United States Men’s National Soccer Team has been accompanied by a wide range of voices behind the microphone, delivering some of the most memorable calls in World Cup history.
Along the way, several standout broadcast duos have helped shape the viewing experience and left a lasting mark on the USMNT landscape.
Here’s a look back at the voices that have defined US World Cup broadcasts since 1990.
1990 FIFA World Cup – Italy
Network: ESPN
Play-by-play: Bob Ley
Color: Paul Gardner
Coverage of the USMNT at the 1990 World Cup was limited, particularly in the early rounds, but Bob Ley emerged as one of the defining voices of soccer on U.S. television during that era. His presence helped introduce a new generation of American fans to the international game, providing context and credibility at a time when the global stage still felt unfamiliar to much of the US audience.
1994 FIFA World Cup – United States of America
1998 FIFA World Cup – France
2002 FIFA World Cup – Japan / South Korea
Networks: ABC / ESPN
Play-by-play: JP Dellacamera
Color: Ty Keough
This play-by-play and color commentary duo called three World Cups for the USMNT, becoming the defining voice of the team during my peak viewing years. Ty Keough the former USMNT midfielder from the late 1970s and early 1980s.
JP Dellacamera stands out as one of, if not the, best play-by-play announcers and remains one of my favorites. While others on this list delivered memorable moments, they didn’t quite match that same level of longevity.
2006 FIFA World Cup – Germany
Networks: ABC / ESPN
Play-by-play: Dave O’Brien
Color: Marcelo Balboa
New England native Dave O’Brien, widely known today for calling major sports across his career, had just one World Cup as the primary play-by-play voice for the USMNT. His run calling USMNT matches, primarily in the mid-2000s on ESPN, was relatively brief but still memorable. While he isn’t as closely associated with the USMNT as some other broadcasters, he was behind the mic for several standout moments during that era.
2010 FIFA World Cup – South Korea
Network: ESPN
Play-by-play: Ian Darke
Color: John Harkes
Ian Darke brought a global voice to American audiences as the lead play-by-play announcer for the USMNT during the 2010 FIFA World Cup. Already well known around the world, he made the tournament easy to connect with for U.S. fans and delivered one of the most iconic calls in American soccer history.
Darke’s iconic call of the USMNT game winning goal by Landon Donovan in must win final group stage match against Algeria to advance to the knockout stage of the 2010 World Cup gives me chills every time I see it.
2014 FIFA World Cup – Brazil
Networks: ESPN / ABC
Play-by-play: Ian Darke
Color: Taylor Twellman
This duo might be my favorite to date. Ian Darke brought a clear, global voice to USMNT viewers during the 2014 FIFA World Cup, making the tournament easy to follow for US fans while elevating the biggest moments with calm, sharp, and memorable calls.
Alongside him, Taylor Twellman emerged as one of the most recognizable and influential voices of the modern era, primarily as a lead analyst on ESPN. His passionate, unfiltered style stood out, most notably with his unforgettable “What are we doing?!” reaction following the USMNT’s failure to qualify for the 2018 World Cup, a moment that’s still talked about today.
2022 FIFA World Cup – Qatar
Network: FOX Sports
Play-by-play: John Strong
Color: Stu Holden
If the USMNT had qualified for the 2018 World Cup, this broadcast team would have called their matches, marking what would have been a third straight World Cup cycle with the same primary commentary crew. It’s also likely he’ll be paired again with Stu Holden for USMNT matches at the 2026 World Cup.
John Strong has served as a lead play-by-play voice for U.S. soccer on FOX Sports since 2018, bringing a modern, high-energy style to the booth. Since taking on major international assignments, he’s become one of the defining voices for USMNT audiences in top competitions, known for his clear, sharp calls and a big-game tone that fits the moment.
The growth and success of Major League Soccer has led to more players from around the world representing MLS at the World Cup, with this summer’s tournament expected to feature the highest total yet.
1998 was the first World Cup played after the launch of Major League Soccer. Here’s a breakdown of MLS-based players on World Cup rosters by year:
1998 – 18 (T-8th) Tied with Liga MX for 8th most. This would the first and only time the USMNT World Cup roster
2002 – 11 (18th) All 11 were from the USMNT
2006 – 15 (14th) 11 of the 15 were #USMNT players.
2010 – 6 (25th) The lowest total to date. Only 6 MLS players, with 4 on the USMNT. This coincided with the peak of US players based in Europe.
2014 – 21 (10th) Less than half were USMNT players, though the US still led the way the 10 most notably DeAndre Yedlin (20) getting the call.
2018 – 18 (11th) This number likely would’ve been significantly higher had the USMNT qualified, potentially pushing MLS into the top 7–8 leagues.
2022 – 36 (6th) The highest total yet, just behind Ligue 1 for 5th. Also worth noting, rosters expanded from 23 to 26 players for this tournament and the first time that the USA didn’t have the most players
Overall, the trend shows steady growth in MLS representation, both domestically and internationally.
MLS Pipeline Continues for the USMNT
It’s rare for a World Cup–qualified nation not to have a strong share of its players featured across tournament rosters. Canada was a recent exception in 2022, though their ties to MLS remain significant with multiple clubs in the league.
With roster selection less than a month away, it’s reasonable to expect that roughly a third of the #USMNT squad will come from MLS. Below is a positional breakdown of the MLS players Mauricio Pochettino has called in during his tenure as USMNT manager.
Goalkeepers
The USMNT is set to start an MLS-based goalkeeper at a World Cup for the first time, with all of the top options currently playing in MLS.
Chris Brady is one of the goalkeepers I’m most excited to watch in the coming cycles. He’s been performing at a high level in Major League Soccer and looks like a strong candidate to fill the long-term role as the USMNT’s primary starter over the next few cycles.
Chris Brady Roman Celentano Matt Freese Patrick Schulte Matt Turner
Defenders
Veteran center-backs Tim Ream and Miles Robinson seem likely to be selected with Blackmon a possibility depending on the health of the remaining pool. Arfsten seems to be almost a lock due to his ability to attack and create scoring chances with his crosses from the wing.
Max Arfsten Tristan Blackmon Tim Ream Miles Robinson
Midfielders
The USMNT has strong depth in midfield, and Mauricio Pochettino’s recent roster selections suggest he’ll likely round out the squad with some of the players listed below.
One of the biggest gaps in this USMNT roster is the true dynamic, creative spark in the attacking third. Diego Luna stands out in that role, capable of unsettling defenses, breaking lines, and changing the rhythm of a match. He’s exactly the type of player who could thrive in a super-sub role, coming on against tired legs and making an impact at this summer’s World Cup.
Sebastian Berhalter Diego Luna Jack McGlynn Cristian Roldan Timothy Tillman
Forwards
Striker may be the toughest position for the MLS group to crack the #USMNT World Cup roster, but Brian White is making a strong case, scoring eight goals in his first nine MLS matches at the time of writing.
Brian White is a highly productive, “old-school” style striker for the USMNT, known for his elite positioning, relentless work rate, and ability to finish in a variety of ways. That combination makes him a strong option as a striker off the bench, where he could be especially dangerous against tired defenses at this summer’s World Cup.
Paxten Aaronson Josh Sargent Brian White
MLS Representation in the USMNT Player Pool
Since 1998, the last time the majority of a USMNT World Cup roster was composed primarily of MLS-based players, it has become increasingly clear that a meaningful portion of the squad still comes from MLS. Consistently, roughly 30–40% of the roster has been drawn from the domestic league, reflecting a long-standing and relatively stable trend in player selection over time which I don’t seen changing anytime soon.
Thomas Deschaine (@uskeeper on X and us_keeper on Instagram)
In light of the recent resignation of Matt Crocker, I revisited something I wrote nearly a decade ago, an early attempt to capture what I called the “Dark Decades of US Soccer.” At the time, the piece was overly long and packed with detail—probably more than today’s audience would stick with.
But buried in that work were meaningful patterns, clear, recurring behaviors that shaped how the federation operated more than 60 years ago. What stood out most, looking back now, is how familiar some of those patterns still feel today.
So, I went back, stripped the piece down, and pulled out the most relevant sections, those that highlight the parallels between past and present. The goal isn’t to draw conclusions for you, but to put those similarities side by side and let you decide: how much has really changed?
World Cup Momentum to the First American Soccer Boom
Soccer star Pele in action during World Cup competition.
Photo of Pele at the 1966 World Cup Photograph: AP Photo
After the success and popularity of the 1966 World Cup which saw over one million viewers of the tournament many America investors saw the vision and believed that there was the market for soccer in the United States and Canada.
The investors moved very quickly and in 1967 there were two American professional leagues making their debuts the USSFA-sanctioned United Soccer Association (USA) and the independent National Professional Soccer League (NPSL).
These leagues would only last one year and be merged at the request of FIFA into the North American Soccer League (NASL) kicking off in 1968 and relying on mainly on foreign talent. The American investors believed building the interest in soccer in the US would have a direct impact on the growth and performance of the US Men’s National team which and of course more money for the investors and federation.
First Attempt at Modernizing the USMNT
Phil Woosnam, in 1977 as the commissioner of the NASL. Photograph: AP Photo
Off the back of the success of the inaugural NASL season, the U.S. Soccer Federation appointed Phil Woosnam, fresh off leading the Atlanta Chiefs to a championship and earning Coach of the Year honors, to take charge of the U.S. Men’s National Team.
Woosnam immediately shifted the structure of the program. Instead of a player pool selected by committee, he pushed decision-making toward the coaching staff, allowing selections to be based on performance and fit rather than geography or internal bias. The move was not universally welcomed, and it reportedly created friction with members of the federation’s leadership.
With professional players now more fully available, Woosnam’s approach helped assemble what was widely considered the strongest possible squad at the time. He also introduced organized training camps ahead of friendlies and World Cup qualifiers, an uncommon practice in that era, but one that clearly improved cohesion and preparation. Those changes contributed to the U.S. advancing further in World Cup qualifying than it had in previous cycles.
By early 1969, the USMNT appeared to be building real momentum toward a potential place in the 1970 World Cup. However, tensions between Woosnam and the federation began to escalate. Frustrated with compensation issues and growing interference from the USSF in team operations, Woosnam stepped away from the national team in the spring of 1969. become commissioner of the NASL.
Following his departure, assistant coach Gordon Jago took over as manager. His tenure began under difficult circumstances, with not being able to set up pre-qualifying friendlies, an important part of the progress made under Woosnam along with interference from USSF board members as it related to roster selection which created instability and morale issues on the field. The USMNT struggled in qualifying and ultimately fell short, losing both matches to Haiti, a team they had previously been competitive with in a series of friendlies in 1968.
The Crocker Era: Coaching Chaos and Course Corrections
Photo of Cindy Parlow Cone, Gregg Berhalter, Matt Crocker and JT Batson Photograph: AP Photo/Lucas Peliter
It’s been roughly three years since the Matt Crocker era began at U.S. Soccer, when he stepped in as Sporting Director, replacing Earnie Stewart.
One of Crocker’s first major responsibilities was hiring the next U.S. Men’s National Team manager. In the previous cycle, the federation had reportedly operated with a narrow set of internal criteria, preferences widely believed to favor English-speaking and American candidates, which significantly limited the coaching pool and shaped the direction of the search.
Roughly two months later, during the Concacaf Nations League semifinal window, it was announced that Gregg Berhalter would be reappointed as USMNT head coach. The decision caught many around the program and in the media off guard, raising questions about how the process had ultimately unfolded.
More recently, in an interview with GiveMeSport, Jesse Marsch stated he was effectively told he was set to become the next USMNT head coach in the late spring of 2023, only for that opportunity to be withdrawn at the last moment, a shift that reportedly had ripple effects on a potential move to Leicester City that was nearing completion.
The abrupt reversal and eventual rehiring of Berhalter has been widely attributed to a mix of factors, including rumored influence from within the player pool, with U.S. Soccer ultimately reversing course. Roughly a year later, after a disappointing Copa América campaign on home soil, Berhalter was dismissed.
Crocker’s second opportunity to reset the program took a different direction. He first secured the high-profile appointment of Emma Hayes, one of the most accomplished managers in women’s football, to lead the USWNT. That move was followed by the hiring of Mauricio Pochettino for the USMNT, a tenure that has delivered mixed early results and will ultimately be judged through the lens of the 2026 World Cup on home soil but truly disappointed that Crocker wouldn’t see through what he helped build, and you have to ask yourself why?